|
Post by Oklahoma City Thunder on Jan 25, 2009 22:47:02 GMT -5
Im opening up the floor to everyone in the league. Ratings are a touchy subject, and I want to hear what everyone thinks. We are doing our (the staff) mid-season evaluation of players in the staff room and everything is being discussed.
Now for your part. I want you to list 3 players that you think are overrated and 3 that are underrated. Please do not pick players from your own teams. Give me their new ratings as well.
Example Template (last year)
Overrated: 1. Ricky Davis 81-77 2. Raef LaFrentz 72-68 3. Darius Miles 73-69
Underrated: 1. Hedo Turkoglu 73-81 2. Jose Calderon 74-79 3. David West 80-85
|
|
|
Post by Oklahoma City Thunder on Jan 25, 2009 22:48:10 GMT -5
Staff, do not post your ideas. I want to hear from the other 23 GM's 1st.
|
|
|
Post by Boston Celtics on Jan 25, 2009 23:13:00 GMT -5
Overrated-
Jermaine O'Neal 86/82 Shawn Marion 89/84 or 85 Tracy McGrady 91/85
Underrated Jose Calderon 79/84 Roger Mason 63/70 Marc Gasol 58/68-69
|
|
|
Post by Denver Nuggets on Jan 25, 2009 23:14:46 GMT -5
Based only from last season Overrated: marion 89-85 keyon martin 83-78 Jo 86-83
Underatted: tim duncan should be 99 yao ming 88...anit no way he should be an 88 with shaq when we all can agree he;s better or just as good as players like bosh,amare and dwight Jose calderon mid 80;s
off the record: Dwight howard best big in the game u can debate timmy d but the dude has been 20/14 the last 2 season. should be rated higher cause there anit nothing much he can do to improve his numbers are also a lot better than any other big.
|
|
|
Post by Oklahoma City Thunder on Jan 26, 2009 0:03:52 GMT -5
Overrated- Jermaine O'Neal 86/82 Shawn Marion 89/84 or 85 Tracy McGrady 91/85 Underrated Jose Calderon 79/84 Roger Mason 63/70 Marc Gasol 58/68-69 Agreed with all of those Boston. Give or take 1 point from each guy. Based only from last season Overrated: marion 89-85 keyon martin 83-78 Jo 86-83 Underatted: tim duncan should be 99 yao ming 88...anit no way he should be an 88 with shaq when we all can agree he;s better or just as good as players like bosh,amare and dwight Jose calderon mid 80;s off the record: Dwight howard best big in the game u can debate timmy d but the dude has been 20/14 the last 2 season. should be rated higher cause there anit nothing much he can do to improve his numbers are also a lot better than any other big. We are not going to be touching ratings of 90+ players too much unless an extreme need be occurs. NBA live gave them these ratings for a reason. So Duncan being a 99 is out of the question. As for D12; Dwight isn't a complete player yet. He is turnover prone and broke from the FT line. He has good footwork but he still needs to work on his post moves. Right now he is scoring mostly on dunks, put backs and just raw power. Once he figures it out, he will be more unstoppable than he is now. Nonetheless, he will be going up.
|
|
|
Post by Oklahoma City Thunder on Jan 26, 2009 0:12:16 GMT -5
Also, might want to take a 2nd look at Shaq's stats before you start blasting him. Much closer than you might think. Plus, Shaq's 88 is boosted.
Shaq - 17.9 ppg, 9.0 rpg, 1.7 apg, 1.6 bpg
Yao - 19.6 ppg, 9.5 rpg, 1.8 apg, 1.7 bpg
|
|
|
Post by Denver Nuggets on Jan 26, 2009 0:35:54 GMT -5
Also, might want to take a 2nd look at Shaq's stats before you start blasting him. Much closer than you might think. Plus, Shaq's 88 is boosted. Shaq - 17.9 ppg, 9.0 rpg, 1.7 apg, 1.6 bpg Yao - 19.6 ppg, 9.5 rpg, 1.8 apg, 1.7 bpg I though we were debating from last year season not this one. This year shaq has earn his 88 but last year to maintain that 88 was kinda questionable when ming destroyed him and earn the number one ranks center until this year where d12. As for d12 yes he does have his flaws but what he's being doing for the past to years even with those flaws has exceeding anything anyone else has done in his position. Like young shaq(not saying d12 is anywhere near young shaq) he had his flaws but dominated the game. D12 fits the bill in today's game there anit one big man in the game capable of guarding this guy. If this guy does become a complete player he would be better than shaq cause shaq was never a complete player. All i'm saying is he should be rated in the top 3 bigs in this league.
|
|
|
Post by Oklahoma City Thunder on Jan 26, 2009 0:43:16 GMT -5
We're talking this season Den. The example template is from last year, thats it.
Sorry for the confusion.
|
|
|
Post by Denver Nuggets on Jan 26, 2009 0:56:37 GMT -5
o well in that case amare 90..how the hell u gonig to let shaq be better than u jo marion
underratted danny g 86 yao ming deron williams
|
|
|
Post by Charlotte Bobcats on Jan 26, 2009 2:04:28 GMT -5
IF YALL MAKE D12 OVER A 92 HE WILL GO NUTS AND COST ME A RING LIKE HE DID IN RIM!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by Atlanta Hawks on Jan 26, 2009 2:16:06 GMT -5
IF YALL MAKE D12 OVER A 92 HE WILL GO NUTS AND COST ME A RING LIKE HE DID IN RIM!!!!!!!!!!! And?
|
|
|
Post by Charlotte Bobcats on Jan 26, 2009 2:46:54 GMT -5
IF YALL MAKE D12 OVER A 92 HE WILL GO NUTS AND COST ME A RING LIKE HE DID IN RIM!!!!!!!!!!! And? And everyone will agree with me that was garbage...I had the 2nd best team but the Spurs weren't ANYWHERE near the top.
|
|
|
Post by theanswer - IND on Jan 26, 2009 4:45:45 GMT -5
overated: Marion-should be-84 Jo-should be-82 Ricky Davis-should be-70
underated: Marc Gasol-should be-70 Stuckey-should be-78 Danny Granger-should be-87
i may edit mine
|
|
|
Post by Washington Wizards on Jan 26, 2009 6:08:30 GMT -5
underated nene 76-79 granger 83-85 randolph 83-86
overrated ford 80-78 peja 81-79 hughes 79-77
|
|
|
Post by seanaes - PHX on Jan 26, 2009 7:12:17 GMT -5
Overrated: Al Horford; 81-78 Shaun Livingston; 72-65 Stephon Marbury; 79-70
Underrated: Jose Calderon; 79-83 Chauncey Billups; 83-88 Tyson Chandler; 82-85
|
|
|
Post by raps03 - TOR on Jan 26, 2009 7:17:21 GMT -5
Overrated-
Vince Carter 88/85 Shawn Marion 89/84 Tracy McGrady 91/85
Underrated Jose Calderon 79/85 Danny Granger 83 - 86 Marc Gasol 58/68-69
OKC question, knowing JO rating will go down next season, how will this effect him in NBA live? Are u going to make him a 83 (or what ever his ranking is) in the game or leave how NBA live has it and just change his ranking here on NBA legends?
|
|
|
Post by Philadelphia 76ers on Jan 26, 2009 8:57:00 GMT -5
VC is putting up 21 / 5 / 5 this season, he still deserves his 88 rating.
|
|
|
Post by Sacramento Kings on Jan 26, 2009 13:08:18 GMT -5
Underrated: Granger- to 84/86 Stuckey- to 77/79 Calderon- to 80/82
Overrated: Jermaine O'Neal- to 81/83 Shawn Marion- to 83/85 Stephon Marbury- to 69/71
|
|
|
Post by sniper on Jan 26, 2009 13:52:32 GMT -5
Overated: Jermaine O'Neal 86-82 Shawn Marion 89-85 Stephon Marbury 79-72
Underated: Paul Millsap 72-77 Jose Calderon 79-81 Marc Gasol 58-72
|
|
|
Post by Boston Celtics on Jan 26, 2009 14:10:37 GMT -5
Overated:Jermaine O'Neal 86-82 Shawn Marion 89-85 Stephon Marbury 79-72 Underated:Danny Granger 83-87 Jose Calderon 79-81 Marc Gasol 58-72 You can't list your own players, if you could, I would have listed Durant.
|
|